On page 242-243...as David shows Oram a petrified egg with a "motionless creature, all finger-like appendages and flattened body with a muscular tail coiled beneath it"...David remarks "In case you were wondering, I had nothing to do with it. It lies as I found it, a supreme example of the Engineers' skill. And also, I suppose of their hubris."
To me these puts the nail in the coffin of the notion that David created the Xenomorph. He merely was trying to follow the steps of the Engineers in what they had done thousands of years prior. I have yet to see the film but am familiar with the general story. I can only assume given the back and forth on this point in the forums that a line such as this does not exist in the movie. Thoughts anyone?
That is the plausible idea I was hoping for. I wish they could have made that clear in the film tho. I am of the belief the Deacon (mural) is what they knew and had created on some level. He at most tweaked and re-created something that had been documented and laid out within their written works.
For me it was made somewhat obvious from the scene with David and Daniels in the room with the scrolls. Who is to say David wrote all those scrolls, maybe he was just adding his findings to scrolls that were already there? It wouldn't make any sense for David to be the "inventor" of the eggs with all the evidence that the alien species was in existence way before David. It is completely possible that David could recreate and/or manipulate the already existing "formula".
To bad Ridley says David actually create it because "i found that much more interesting ". :(
That defiantly makes more since with the mural from Prometheus but I think it's very clear David will make the biomechanical features to the Xenomorphs later.
Now since Ridley is basically in control of the franchise now what he says goes. He says "Let change it to David creating the Xenomorphs" then that's what will happen.
Still have wiggle room there, kept referring to it and him - could just be the current and later incarnations or evolutions of the creatures. As scattered as his interviews have been, they were also carefully worded so that if backlash hit key points, basically everything could be tuned around it in the future.
I'm curious as to whether Alan Dean Foster added this without Ridley's knowledge as his own interpretation. He may have just assumed it was the case. On the other hand, Foster was perhaps shown an uncut version of the film that included David saying this.
I agree, the point is he didnt invent the xenomporph, his goal was to create life...be a creator.
As Holloway stated in Prometheus "That there is nothing special about the creation of life. Right? Anybody can do it. All you need is a dash of DNA and half a brain"
this essentially what David has done
Sign in to add a reply to this topic!