Alien Movie Universe

Alien: Engineers - What Prometheus Could Have Been
Scified2015-01-28 12:43:21
Written by Chris45,004 Reads14 Comments2015-01-28 12:43:21

Today we look back at the original story for Prometheus, prior to Damon Lindelof's edit of the film's script. Back when Ridley Scott and Fox decided to revisit the popular Alien franchise, Jon Spaihts was hired to pen the script for Scott's Alien Prequel. The original title of the film was going to be Alien: Engineers and roughly 5 rewrites of this script took place before Lindelof was brought on to make some last minute changes; some of which resonated poorly with certain fans, who had expected a direct prequel to the 1979 classic. Prometheus in its own right was a great film with a lot of open ends which left audiences speculating on its secrets to this day, just like Scott's original Alien movie, though many fans forget the vagueness of that film as well since it's regarded to highly in the sci-fi community. However, before Prometheus took flight, the original plan for this prequel was in fact to focus on the horrific Xenomorph alien once again and reveal its origins alongside the explanation of the LV-426 Space Jockey. 

Following the release of Prometheus in 2012, around November of the same year, the script entitled "Alien: Engineers" had leaked online and we had reached out to its scribe, Jon Spaihts for confirmation of its authenticity. Through Twitter, the screenwriter confirmed the script was one of the final drafts he had submitted before Fox decided to bring on Lindelof. Alien: Engineers is an entirely different beast than Prometheus and would certainly have made for an intense, high-octane thrill ride for fans of the franchise. Below is a run down of the major similarities and differences between Spaihts' original script versus Damon Lindelof's rewrite.

The script starts off by describing a very similar opening scequence, where a large spacecraft is seen hovering over a planet, with a sacrificial Engineer taking some kind of alien technology (not black goo like in Prometheus) and then disintegrating, seeding the planet with its DNA to kick-start evolution. Unlike Prometheus, instead of the Engineer drinking a black liquid substance, refered to as "bio-former" or "black goo" by fans, in Spaihts' draft, the Engineer allows himself to be bitten by small scarab-like creatures, which inject him with DNA-altering venom.

Just like in Prometheus, we're then introduced to the film's primary characters, Holloway and Shaw, however in the Alien: Engineers script, Shaw's name was refered to as Watts. The difference here is Holloway and Watts/Shaw discover their final star map, underwater, as opposed to the Isle of Skye.

In Spaihts' script the two scientists are then taken to an orbiting space station known as "Weyland's Wheel", much the tune of the station seen in Elysium. This is where the two meet Mr. Weyland before they embark on their journey. This is also where they convince Weyland that this mission is worth funding and agree to the voyage - an exchange that was left out in Prometheus.

Another difference is the name of the ship. Before the ship's name was known as "Prometheus", the original name for the deep space vessel was known as the "USCSS Magellan" and the moon in which they land on was not LV-223, but in fact, LV-426; the moon they land on in Alien and return to again in James Cameron's Aliens. Also, unlike in Prometheus, in Alien: Engineers, the reason for which the Magellan crew decide to set down on LV-426 is because the ship picks up unnatural formations and mineral clusters across the planet's surface. These are later discovered to be ancient Engineer pyramids - similar to the ones seen in Prometheus however they were described as being more metallic looking than stone.

The crew venture into the pyramid structure and just like in Prometheus, Fifield and Milburn get lost and must wait out the storm, but there's a reason why they got lost - each thought the other had the map. Holloway and Watts discover a pile of dead Engineers, much like what we see in Prometheus, but the difference here, is Holloway gets lost, wandering down a hallway and falls down a shaft, into a chamber full of Alien eggs. His helmet smashes and he's later discovered by David and Watts and transported back to the Magellan.

As the story progresses, Fifield and Milburn wander aimlessly throughout the pyramid until they come in contact with the Hammerpede. Milburn's death wasn't changed but in Spaihts' draft, Fifield isn't coated in the black goo, but is attacked by those scarabs, like the ones seen decomposing the Engineer at the beginning of the story. Once they break through his suit by ejecting drops of acid, they get inside and bite him - injecting him with DNA-altering venom.

Following those main differences, the plot continues on as it does in Prometheus, however one difference is while examining the severed Engineer head they discover in the pyramid, Watts/Shaw discovers something really neat. it's referred to as the Vision of the Gods. Watts has one of the crew actually extract the Engineer's eye lense and equip them to a pair of goggles, allowing Watts to essentially "see the way an Engineer would see" - which is described as very "bright". Engineers can apparently see living organisms through solid surfaces, they can see an ora around them, like a glowing outline. It was interesting to imagine what this could have looked like, had it been added to the film. But, this allowed Shaw to witness more of the spectacles which were present in the Orrey room as the Engineer started up the Juggernaut.

Another difference is when Holloway is brought back to the ship, instead of getting torched by Vickers, he actually gives birth to an octopus-like Facehugger, which gets loose on the ship. This is where the story really picks up. We then learn that David has found a hatchery under the pyramid, where instead of "URNS with Black Goo", the Engineers were engineering creatures, designed to kill Humans, and planned to take them to Earth. But because they made their creations "too well", and because the Engineers shared many same characteristics as Humans, their creations turned on them and killed them all... all except for one.


Also, instead of Shaw having sex with Holloway and contracting the alien DNA that way, David actually impregnates Shaw/Watts, by holding her down while a Facehugger crawls out of its egg and latches onto her face. In this scene, we learn that there were many different types of Aliens/Facehuggers. The one that impregnates Holloway is like an Octopus, with no bones, yet still very strong, while the one that impregnates Shaw/Watts was boney, and armored, like the classic Facehugger we see in ALIEN. Shaw/Watts later awakens to a dead Facehugger lying beside her and a red ring around her neck. She manages to escape David and get back to the ship where she frantically goes into the Med Pod and removes the grotesque Chestburster which was gestating inside her. In this scene, Shaw/Watts passes out during the recovery procedure, and her Alien baby grows up quite rapidly and kills one of the Weyland Security officers on board, in Vickers' suite. Shaw watches as it kills the officer and then begins feeding on him.

After awakening a third time inside the MedPod, as the MedPod doors open, Shaw manages to slowly and quietly, escape and grab the officer's gun, pumping a full clip into the Alien, causing it to die and drench the floor in acid, which eventually melts through a couple levels of the ship as it falls through. At the same time, whatever Holloway gave birth to is killing people inside the Magellan.

In Spaihts' script we also see the Engineer kill a Xenomorph, which had been born from the character Chance earlier in the plot, by grabbing it around the neck and snapping it in two. The sheer power of the Engineer is immense as its described to have mangled the Xenomorph with ease.

As the Engineer kills everyone but Watts/Shaw, she escapes and the Engineer fires up the Juggernaut. But something goes wrong and as the ship ascends, the Engineer gives birth to a massive Chesburster, causing the ship to crash land back on LV-426. From this, spanws the "Ultramorph", a massive Alien.


Back on the Magellan, Janek gets killed by this Ultramorph, and Watts runs and hides from it, barely being caught. The Ultramorph locates the Engineer head, which has been sitting in preservative and begins to feed on it.

Shaw makes a little noise after finding a chainsaw, which she hopes to use to kill the Ultramorph, but the Ultramorph finds her. In a quick move, Shaw swings the chainsaw, cutting off one of the Ultramorph's hands, but the Ultramorph manages to pin her down with a large spike on the end of its tail, leaving Shaw just out of reach of the chainsaw. She eventually manages to slide herself far enough up to grab it and slices the Ultramorph's head off, sending acid everywhere. At this point, as the acid begins to corrode her space suit, Shaw/Watts has to move quickly to get out of her space suit, before the acid burns through it. She manages to get out of it in time, but is left standing, with no helmet, in the toxic air of LV-426. Thankfully, she gets to Vickers' suite and grabs a fresh suit.

She later meets up with David, who has all of a sudden changed his ways from being evil and sinister to hopeful that she will rebuild him, but the film ends with the pyramids lighting up, almost like a beacon, insinuating that more Engineers will come to investigate what happened.

It's clear many plot elements were changed from Spaihts' Alien: Engineers to Lindelof's Prometheus. The reason being Fox wanted to spawn a new trilogy and Ridley Scott wanted to focus less on the Xenomorph and more on the Engineers. Either way, Jon Spaihts' script was an entertaining read, and would certainly have made for an enjoyable movie. Many copies of the script have been removed from the web, but you can still find a copy here if you wish to read it for yourself.

What do you think of Alien: Engineers? Would you have prefered this to be the plot of Prometheus? Would you like to see some of Jon Spaihts' plot elements make it into one of the Prometheus sequels? Let us know in the comments section!

More Alien Movie Universe News & Articles

Do you have news to share on Fede Álvarez's Alien: Romulus? Click here to submit any information you have, or to ask any questions! Browse other conversations about Alien: Romulus by other Alien fans in the Alien: Romulus forums here.

Visit the Alien TV Series forums to browse topics about the upcoming TV series by Nah Hawley as well! Got news for the Alien TV series? You can share that too, here!



MemberChestbursterJan-28-2015 5:30 PM

It's LV-426! Not LV-246!


MemberChestbursterJan-28-2015 5:39 PM

Also, I would have watched this. I wish they made this. This sounds awesome. I hope they do something like this in the sequel. Or at least include the Xenomorphs.

Seventeen days??

MemberOvomorphJan-29-2015 7:01 AM

This would be sooo much better! Prometheus is a good movie, but reading this, they could have made amazing movie. I hope Mr.Scott will be also reading fan comments, and include more xenomorps and original Alien like feeling to the movie.


AdminPraetorianJan-29-2015 8:31 AM

I actually prefer Lindelof's ideas. At least he tried to be somewhat original, though I thought the black goo reminded me a bit too much of the X-Files black oil... I don't think Spaith's version would have turned out any better than the disaster that Prometheus was, it's mostly wishful thinking to beleive otherwise. 

John Willis

MemberOvomorphJan-29-2015 2:20 PM

Seems much more straight forward and relatably motivated. Clearly distinguishes "The Engineers" from us, doesn't make the mysterious "Weyland Corporation" the big bad and setup the "we are our own worst enemy" trope.

Good adventure movies that reveal a villian that is simple to understand are often more satisfying. If we have to wonder if they are just being true to their nature and aren't really 'Evil' it kind of takes all the fun out of it. It also looses a big portion of the audience who doesn't spend three hours pondering the soul of the enemy.

Prometheus suffered a huge plot hole where motivations were concerned, we're left never really meeting an Engineer.. the reanimated head and reconstituted freeze dried Engineer just dont' count.. we're left wondering if they are/were our benefactors who are Evil or turned Evil because of something we ourselves did. Self loathing seems too favorite a pastime in a lot of Ridley Scott films.. wished it were more on a simple level playing field.. sometimes Monsters.. are Monsters.. simply because of what they do.. no psychiatry involved. I really don't want to empathize with them for killing the entire crew... because it wasn't their fault.

I worry whenever I see a movie that devolves into supercritical ananlysis they are winding up to defuse the confrontation.. before it actually comes.. as if the "Aliens" fight scenes never happened because we pulled a "Vulcan Mind Meld" with them and setup a peace treaty.. lol.

David counts as a third race.. we're left wondering if he's motivated by innocent curiosity, Weyland orders to seek out financial gain for the bioweapons division (aka James Cameron's - Aliens) or perhaps seeking a slave against master rebellion to allow Artificial Intelligence to subjugate the human race.. or something else.. possibly switching allegiances from human to Engineers race? All rarely explored topics... and possibly political hot potatos in other parts of the world where the film is released.. so safer to leave it subtext and unexplained. The whole Androids turning against their masters unexplained subplot has dragged on for years.. and now we have the David, Vickers, Bishop, Ash quadrangle.. they could be an entire Fifth Column that could end up betraying or representing a threat to both Humans and Engineers.




MemberOvomorphJan-29-2015 7:50 PM

These are cool plot variations, but I agree with Svanya that Lindelof's version amounts to a more interesting narrative about who these Engineers are, and ultimately what a xenomorph is. This comes bregrudgingly because I think Lindelof is a hack. 

But seriously, how much can a script tell us about how good or bad a film is going to be? Who can really take credit or the blame? Has anyone read Dan O'Bannon's original Alien? It's not that great, and was re-written 20 times by Fox. 

So to answer Chris's question: I would like to see Noomi Rapace cut something open with a chainsaw--but first I want to know why you need a chainsaw in space!



MemberOvomorphJan-31-2015 5:39 PM

Way better script!


MemberXenomorphFeb-24-2015 2:24 AM

prometheus is a great movie.


but you have to understand where it came from - and why ....that is something you cant explain to someone in 50 words.. 


the potential it has mindblowing


i hope p2 comes just close to that potential.


spaihts script was great - but it eliminated the whole success of the franchise - the sj mystery and xeno origins.

i have come now to the end of a long journey - writing - script writing - movie making is an art - going somewhere new with a story is incredibly difficult. and requires some very special talent.

alien as someone said today was a collaberative effort made by many people hence the better chance of alien  being a success.

ridley had way too much say in prometheus it now seems.

perhaps if they try a collaberative effort again for p2 it might work. why does one person get all the say ??

therfore i agree on bringing in lindeloff but you need to read the weyland industries website to get a decent feel for the movie.

so perhaps fox should hire a team of writers to test those ideas amongst themselves and then settle on something.


who knows


MemberOvomorphFeb-28-2015 10:09 AM

In my personal opinion, the Guion of, Alien Engineers is basic, child and little credible, more shoves a world more gore with quality worthy of a low-budget film.


MemberOvomorphMar-09-2015 11:44 AM

Prometheus was kind of an alien prequell but the only two related Alien references to this was the Weylan-Yutani corporation, and the Engineer ship. Not a single mention of the Xenomorph was mentioned, or introduced. So hopefully that is fixed in Prometheus 2.


MemberOvomorphMar-12-2015 11:09 PM

I always like Lindelofs input with Spaights draft its always better to have the two ideas together into one cohesive plot. The Ancient Engineers needed to be shown more than a xenomorph anyway, to me even though I love the Alien creature..its still just an animal with a hive mind intelligence and no cognitive sentient mind. The biblical and other ancient myths that were in this movie are put in so well. I dont give Lindelof flack because I never watched LOST  to me it didnt matter who made the show it BLOWED. So when I heard that he wrote for that show. It never got to me so when he wrote the Prometheus draft with those deep meanings about who we are and where we come from was cool.


MemberOvomorphMar-13-2015 6:23 PM

So, Ridley Scott has publicly stated more than once that he makes movies for himself, nobody else.   When you look at his life I think you gain some insight into the plotline of Prometheus.

A central element of Prometheus, especially when you factor in some of the ancillary viral marketing material, is Weyland's desperate lunge for immortality.  He spends all that money and lives just to cheat death, as he admits.  All his great, almost god-like accomplishments cannot spare him that fate.  For me, this is really the heart of the story, and if you watch it (several times) you can see the foreshadowing and the importance of this element.

So Ridley is in his 70s, and his younger brother Tony threw himself off a bridge in 2012 after being diagnosed with a brain tumor of the same type that killed their older brother when they were in their early 20s.  Ridley knew Tony had cancer and was undergoing chemo, and probably knew while Prometheus was in development. 

He no doubt is acutely aware of his own mortality at this point and is trying to crank out accomplishments as he feels his time speeding by.  When you look at all that, and then watch Prometheus again, this provides a plausible explanation for why he had Lindelof rewrite the script the way that he did.  And  make no mistake, Ridley supervised the rewrite, both he and Lindelof stated that repeatedly.




MemberFacehuggerMay-18-2015 11:00 AM

Hopefully they decide to make this movie regardless or someone decides to make this into a fan film


MemberChestbursterFeb-02-2017 4:28 AM

Spaihts' script was an interesting read and it's definitely scarier. It's interesting that the setting is on LV-426 and that the space-jockey is explained (although it can't be "fossilised"). It looks (judging by the trailer) as if some of Spaihts creepier ideas will "crawl" into Alien: Covenant?

Add A Comment
Sign In Required
Sign in using your Scified Account to access this feature!
Visitor Comments
Latest Images
Alien & Predator Alien & Predator Fandom
Latest Features
Alien: Romulus Movie Trailers Updated 2024-07-18 11:51:15
Get Tickets for Alien: Romulus! Updated 2024-07-11 12:11:21
Alien: Romulus Spoilers Updated 2024-07-07 18:01:48
Everything we know about Alien: Romulus Updated 2024-06-15 10:35:44
Alien Movie Universe Forums
Alien: Romulus
Alien: Romulus Discuss the new Fede Alvarez Alien movie here
Alien: Earth Series
Alien: Earth Series Discuss the Alien FX TV series here!
Alien: Covenant
Alien: Covenant Discuss the Prometheus Sequel, Alien: Covenant
Alien Movies
Alien Movies Discuss the Classic Alien Films
Alien 5 Movie
Alien 5 Movie Discuss Neill Blomkamps’s vision for Alien 5 here
Alien Games
Alien Games Discuss Alien games here
Alien Discuss all things Alien here
Prometheus Everything About Prometheus
Prometheus Fan Art
Prometheus Fan Art Artwork & Fiction From the Fans
Hot Forum Topics
New Forum Topics
Highest Forum Ranks Unlocked
Thoughts_Dreams » Neomorph
85% To Next Rank
Neomorph » Chestburster
84% To Next Rank
Jonesy » Facehugger
94% To Next Rank
Xenowarrior » Ovomorph
22% To Next Rank
Benknows » Ovomorph
12% To Next Rank
Latest Alien Fandom Activity

This website provides the latest information, news, rumors and scoops on the Alien: Romulus movie and Alien TV series for FX! Get the latest news on the Alien prequels, sequels, spin-offs and more. Alien movie, game and TV series news is provided and maintained by fans of the Alien film franchise. This site is not affiliated with 20th Century Studios, FX, Hulu, Disney or any of their respective owners.

© 2024
Sign in
Use your Scified Account to sign in

Log in to view your personalized notifications across Scified!

Transport To Communities
Alien Hosted Community
Cloverfield Hosted Community
Godzilla Hosted Community
Jurassic World Hosted Community
Predator Hosted Community
Aliens vs. Predator Hosted Community
Latest Activity
Search Scified
Trending Articles
Blogs & Editorials
Featured Forum Discussions
Forums & Community
Sci-Fi Movies
Help & Info