Trending Network Articles
Cold Iron Studios' Alien Game
Cold Iron Studios Alien Game
New / Upcoming Alien Titles
Upcoming Alien Titles
Alien Movies
Alien Movies
Featured Content
Alien Discussion Forums

Difference between ambiguity and poor writing

496 Views6 RepliesAdd A Reply
Forum Topic


Member0 XPJun-23-2012 11:47 PMOkay, this will be the last review I post. But it is such a good one and answers the whole "you just want all the answers spoon fed to you" raps dislikers get. It is from (someone to hear me scream) by, who else, sarah ditum. If this has already been posted, I apologize Jun 09 2012 7 Comments By Sarah Ditum Film Someone to hear me scream: the problem with Prometheus The best things about Prometheus are the things that aren’t explicitly do to with the Alien series, which makes it a shame that the film has been crafted and sold as part of the Alien series, because the most disappointing thing about Prometheus is that it’s not really an Alien film. Sure, it has the motifs of an Alien film: tough female heroes, reproduction as horror, face raping space vaginas. But its addition to that world diminishes rather than expands the mythology – and as I’m going to talk about that mythology in some detail, spoilers are pretty much inevitable from here. (And after you’re done reading this, go and see what the brilliant Nathan has to say about the same showing of the same film. I think he liked it more than I did.) Prometheus is an origins story, for both humans and the alien, as archeologists Shaw and Holloway (Noomi Rapace and Logan Marshall-Green) lead an expedition in search of what they think could be the species that created humanity – referred to as “the engineers”. What they find is a lot of dead engineers and a huge puddle of black goo that has bizarre and unpleasant effects on everything it touches. Writer Damon Lindelof has explained (in one of the many, many interviews he’s given for Prometheus) that he was conscious of the way prequels can close off a story, and explicitly tried to avoid that in the script he wrote: “We wanted Prometheus to open up the universe, so it’s not a prequel at all.” And that puddle was intended to supply Prometheus’ ambiguity: “There’s a speculative part of it – the question becomes, ‘What does the black goo do?’ That is the question that you’re supposed to be asking coming out of this movie.” Only, the question I was asking as I left Prometheus wasn’t, “What does the black goo do?” Coming out of the movie, I felt pretty confident, actually, that I knew what the black goo did. What the black goo does is “anything that might advance the story” – from seeding human DNA, to turning worms into savage nob snakes, to turning unfortunate geologists into pitiable and vicious monsters, to putting a squid baby inside Noomi Rapace. What the black goo does is ambiguous, then, but only in the sense that it’s unconfined – its abilities seep and spread to wherever the movie wants a creature for a set-piece. I’ve recently been reading Richard Sennett’s book The Craftsman, which has this to say about ambiguity: Any skilled writer doles out any sort of ambiguity like very good wine – that is, sparingly. We can make an expressive point about hanging stories or unresolved characters if we do not leave them hanging or unresolved too often. My beef with Prometheus is that, even though it may well have an expressive point about hanging stories and unresolved characters (and John Warrender makes that case eloquently in this blogpost), the film itself handles ambiguity ineptly in scene after scene. The notable exception to this is Michael Fassbender as android David, with his unguessably inhuman motives; but he’s also a means to demolish ambiguity, using his robo-powers to snoop on Shaw’s subconscious while she’s in suspended animation and uncover to the audience the formative loss on which her religious faith is based. There’s more in the same vein. As Shaw and Holloway share an intimate moment in her cabin around the midpoint of the movie, he (an atheist) teases her about the ease with which the engineers appear to have created life. “I can’t create life,” she moans, and turns towards her pillow. It would be a flat-flooted revelation in any film, clearly intended for the audience rather than sounding like the organic, easy conversation of lovers and colleagues who must be long used to the fact of her infertility. In a film that belongs to the Alien world, where we know to be on the lookout for malignant reproduction and strange maternity, the line thuds through like a mech suit. Sure enough, a few scenes later, she’s told that she’s pregnant – and there’s no surprise, because the surprise was so thoroughly set up. The auto-abortion she performs is a high horror moment (the best in the film), but sold short when it immediately gives way to another foreshadowed shock (surprise! That old guy they said was dead is not dead after all!). And worst of all, when Shaw discovers the ancient and not-dead Weyland, he’s attended by the same two members of crew Shaw earlier twatted in the head with a metal bar in order to escape so she could get rid of the Squidward jr swimming in her belly. Neither of them seem surprised to see her. Which is odd. That kind of narrative illogic sucks all the power away from the ambiguity that’s supposed to be important: when there are things that don’t make sense all over a film, the question of “what the black goo does” is no more meaningful than the question “why doesn’t anyone care that Shaw is naked, covered in blood and full of staples?” But maybe my biggest disappointment in Prometheus is that meaning should matter at all. It’s a film that rewards the hunt for answers, even if it doesn’t give any. At the end of the film, the sole human survivor is Shaw, headed to the engineers’ homeworld with the assistance of a decapitated David. The one with faith – the one who sought solutions – gets away. The real horror of the alien, though, is that it has always had a completely self-sufficient, mundanely Darwinist explanation. Why does the alien want to hurt us? Because that’s how the alien survives. There’s no animus, only life. Hinting that the alien has a proxy human motivation by implying it’s the product of the engineers’ own motives just makes it less scary. It puts the alien on our level, when the first two films were coldly insistent that we see ourselves from the parasite’s perspective. Alien and Aliens are clean, sharp storytelling with a soul-shaking uncertainty: does being human mean anything if this creature can just use you as an incubator? Prometheus implies that even our status as prey has something to do with our specialness to the engineers. If I feel special, I feel reassured rather than frightened – and a sci-fi that comforts rather than questions is doing the opposite of what I want from my science fiction. Prometheus’ biggest mistake is giving us someone to hear us scream.
6 Responses to Difference between ambiguity and poor writing


Member0 XPJun-24-2012 1:23 AMShe makes several very good points, and I'll add another to this movie's sloppy foreshadowing: the quick cuts to Vickers looking down during Weyland's hologram speech leave no doubt that she will be revealed as his daughter. The one question I have with the review is that I don't think the staff Shaw assaulted prepping her for stasis were same ones tending to Weyland. I do have a problem that her condition is never mentioned and the people she did ding (Ford was one of them, I think) never acknowledged it.

The High Priest

Member0 XPJun-24-2012 2:07 AMThe moment for me when Prometheus completely went down the shitter was when Shaw "broke out" of quarantine - nobody followed her, then after the "set play" token "horror" moment she stumbled in all bloodied to see Weyland...that whole chain of events was just simply amateur writing! It could have so easily been avoided by writing down many paths,(how about she WAS pursued and somehow locked herself in the med pod room? The birth occurs as crew members are struggling to break down the door? You know Im just thinking off the top of my head - there are myriad possibilities) instead lazy writing won the match. I cant accept when "professionals" get the basics so very badly wrong.


Member0 XPJun-24-2012 2:19 AMwell, yes. And Fifield and Milburn could've just as well wandered off to do some Geological/Biological surveying of the temple, instead of subjecting us to the cringe-worthy "I love rocks" bit, and running off like unprofessional wimps. Many opportunities missed...Ridley, much as I love him, just grew a tin ear for much of this film

Hadley's Hope

Member0 XPJun-24-2012 2:51 AMSome good points there, some of the foreshadowing felt forced particularly the 'I can't make life' bit.

The High Priest

Member0 XPJun-24-2012 6:01 AM@Jim100a100 Absolutely - How about Fifield has been expressing his love for rocks from the start of the movie - he just keeps banging on about it. Then when they touch down on a new alien world he is in heaven, he's constantly picking up rocks and examining them, Milburn too could have been a really intelligent but overexcited dude - They wander off in the temple in absolute awe at all the new information, then they have some accident, a rock fall, fall down into another unreachable level chamber - you know the exciting possibilities are actually endless - Instead Lindelturd wrote them as two boring cliche filled goons who just serve to irritate, and he writes his way down the path of least resistance. Epic fail The lack of imagination used by the writers is actually quite startling, even disturbing and worrying.

colonial soldier

Member0 XPJun-24-2012 10:50 AMExcellent post. A good movie that was ambiguous and had an excellent ending was Christopher Nolan's Inception when the top kept spinning so you did not know whether Leo made it out from his dream. Congratulations to Prometheus for making over 100 million US. You know belong in this category. [url=]Awful money makers[/url]
Add A Reply
Log in to Post
Enter Your E-Mail
Enter Your Password

Stay Logged In
Scified Network
Godzilla-Movies.comHosted Community
JurassicWorld3.netHosted Community
Alien-Covenant.comHosted Community
Hosted Community
Predator4-Movie.comHosted Community
New Alien: Covenant Forum Topics
Latest Alien Fandom Activity
Get this Prometheus sweater!
Alien Sweater

Alien: Covenant is a sequel to 2012's Prometheus as well as a prequel to 1979's ALIEN. Alien fans looking to know more about Alien: Covenant should check back often. is an information resource for film enthusiasts looking to learn more about the upcoming blockbuster Alien: Covenant. Providing the latest official and accurate information on Alien: Covenant, this website contains links to every set video, viral video, commercial, trailer, poster, movie still and screenshot available. This site is an extension of the Alien & Predator Fandom on Scified - a central hub for fans of Alien and Prometheus looking to stay up-to-date on the latest news. Images used are property of their respective owners. Alien: Covenant, Prometheus and its associated names, logos and images are property of 20th Century Fox and are in no way owned by Scified and its related entities. This is a fan-created website for the purpose of informing and exciting fans for Alien: Covenant's release. If you have any questions about this site, its content or the Scified Network in general, feel free to contact Scified directly.

Scified is an entertainment media network covering the latest news on the most popular, upcoming science fiction movies, games and television. All content is property of unless otherwise stated. Images and names of content we promote, discuss, review or report are property of their respective owners. Scified is independantly owned and operated by a team of dedicated sci-fi movie fans, who strive to provide the best information and community experience for other like-minded sci-fi movie enthusiasts.

© 2021