David Fincher doing another Alien movie
Posted Jan-29-2017 8:10 AM
It seems interesting to consider the final product of another Fincher movie (except one where he is present from start to finish.) He is much more experienced now than he was when he did Alien 3 and has no doubt given a lot of thought to what went wrong with it.
Would another Fincher film be a mistake?
If he did another film should he work with Cameron?
Taking it a step further, if Ridley were to pass on before he could complete the Prometheus quadrilogy, would it be out of the question to have Cameron and Fincher finish it together?
Posted Jan-29-2017 8:22 AM
I also gave this a thought a while ago, it's a good question.
First of all I think A3 not only left a bad taste in fans' mouths, but also in Fincher's himself.
Fincher's Se7en and Fight Club are some of the best films ever made imo, and he went on to make several fantastic films.
He knows how to scare us and present a thrilling bone chilling story, but maybe not an Alien film on par with the first two.
I don't think Cameron or Ridley would like to cooperate with Fincher or any other director for that matter.
Fincher is a master director but I'm sure they all want full artistic control.
Posted Jan-29-2017 10:20 AM
Even though I disagree, I'm actually glad that someone considers Alien 3 a masterpiece.
For me it's a good film with some very compelling and sad moments. Weaver further showcased her dramatic range here, with her sacrificial scene being so damn powerful.
I'd be more inclined to love if it wasn't so dull in terms of atmosphere, maybe add more exterior shots of the facility and surrounding environment with action taking place outside as well, to maintain the sense of a sci-fi film taking place on another planet.
The visual style is typically Fincher, with a cranked up color scheme, but the atmosphere feels so boring which took away a lot of the horror imo even though that was probably the whole idea.
Posted Jan-29-2017 11:46 AM
Personally i rank a3 under them all. I didnt like it at all..didnt like the plot didnt like the xeno design and its origin and didnt like the characters story..i liked the aestetics of their surroundings but the stroy for me is dreadfull.
For me blomkamp with cameron all the way or alone. I trust the guy.
Posted Jan-29-2017 12:24 PM
I really like Alien 3,mainly the assembly cut.I love David Fincher's movies,and i think he's a better director than James Cameron and Ridley Scott these days.Ridley is very hit and miss,and Cameron's last two movies(Titanic and Avatar)are my least favorite films of his.There's only one Fincher film i'm not the biggest fan of and that would be Benjamin Button.All that aside I would love to see him return but it's extremely unlikely.A partnership with Cameron might work because they are friends,but for Fincher it was such a negative experience that i just don't think he'd do it.He's an amazing film makers(the best around right know in my opinion)but it's never going to happen.
Posted Jan-29-2017 12:31 PM
I liked Alien 3 despite its flaws. The atmosphere, the performances, there were so many good things about it. I would love to see Fincher do another Alien film. As for Cameron, despite loving Aliens, I could care less what he does in the future, and given his current attitude toward the Alien franchise, I think its best he stay as far away from it as possible.
Posted Jan-29-2017 12:39 PM
25 years later Cameron is still calling 3 a slap in the face.I love Aliens,it's my favorite movie,but he needs to stop acting like he owns the franchise.After this guy thinks AVP is the third best film in the franchise.I'm happy about his return to Terminator,it's his franchise after all,but he should stay away from Alien.I wouldn't mind him returning but it's better if he doesn't.
Posted Jan-29-2017 12:45 PM
The deaths of Newt, Hicks, Ripley and Bishop will always sour Alien 3 for me. I hate that aspect of the film so much that it can't be redeemed. Neither can David Fincher as a director of future films. I can appreciate aspects of it, but I'd never want him helming another Alien film.
Safe? Of course he isn't safe, but he's good!
Posted Jan-29-2017 12:54 PM
Their deaths aren't a problem for me,well at least Ripley's isn't.Hicks and Newt should have been on screen and Bishop felt like a plot device.Not Fincher's faut though,the blame falls on Giler and Hill.On a side note Myrrdin,if Ripley's chestburster is something you dislike,then you might take comfort in knowing that the assembly cut removes it.
Posted Jan-29-2017 1:27 PM
It would be rather silly for Ripley to fight the Xenos countless times like she was an invulnerable superhero when she wasn't, she might as well have died in Aliens.
She survived Nostromo and the colony on LV-426, and Fiorina 161 up to the point of her well-needed sacrifice to finally end her long stretched storyline.
Posted Jan-29-2017 1:39 PM
Really, she never should have encountered the Xenos again, period, but my opinion of Alien 3 is purely subjective. It's no more valid than anyone else's, but it's unlikely to change because it's based entirely on how I feel about it, not any strong factual argument.
Safe? Of course he isn't safe, but he's good!
Posted Jan-29-2017 1:56 PM
That's a very good comparison ninxeno, and one of the reasons why I only prefer the first game where he also didn't drop ridiculous one liners.
Isaac Clarke, similar to Ellen Ripley, was wasn't supposed to be a soldier initially, yet ironically they eventually turned him into a super soldier and stretched his story through further two games to an unnecessary trilogy.
I actually love the Dead Space lore, but they should've introduced new protagonists imo.
Posted Jan-29-2017 2:07 PM
Don't get me wrong Dead Space 2 is fantastic, especially at the start. But the slash fest Clarke endures makes the original premise less original and realistic (sorry Aorta ;) imo.
I'm looking forward to a new Dead Space running on Frostbite engine or something, just look at how amazing ME Andromeda looks.
Sign in to add a reply to this topic!